What People Are Saying About Us!

The food is also Amazing!

Wedding Wire Testimonials

We used Irish Coffee Pub as our caterer for our wedding at Martha Clara Vineyards over Memorial Day weekend. It was amazing! First of all, Stephen is wonderful to work with. He is extremely detail-oriented and organized. He responds to emails and calls immediately and was super communicative. He’s also really flexible and was so willing to work with us to make sure everything was just as we wanted it. The food is also AMAZING! We are still getting compliments on the hors d’oeuvres. The cocktail hour was perfectly timed, the servers were attentive and friendly, and the food was out of this world. The quantity and quality is just amazing, and they’re very reasonably priced. The dinner was also excellent. We gave our guests a choice of steak, chicken, and fish, and everyone has told us that their food was delicious.
All in all, I can’t say enough about how wonderful Irish Coffee Pub is. The quality of the food and the wonderful experience working with Stephen can’t be beat. I highly recommend them!


…dinner to desert it was seamless and delicious!!!!

The Knot Testimonials

We have friends that drive over an hour to pick up fresh lobster.. they told us they have never had a dinner like they had at our wedding. Stephen was a dream to work with, and its so nice to just trust someone and know they will do an amazing job. People are still ranting about the food everything from appetizers to dinner to desert it was seamless and delicious!!!!

Jennifer T

Absolute perfection!

My husband and I recently had our 25th wedding anniversary at the Irish coffee pub. Everything was amazing! Absolute perfection! All staff went above and beyond to make our day special. The service was fantastic, the food was absolutely delicious and everything was beautiful. We have also eaten there while making our arrangements prior to our affair and can’t say enough wonderful things about this place!! We will be back many times over in the future!!

Geree Doherty-Zoccali

Not Enough Stars to Rate this Gem

The Irish Coffee Pub NEVER fails to be a delicious culinary treat and fabulous experience where youare treated like dear friends.
Not ENOUGH stars to rate this GEM of Long Island.
Godbless all the crew there.

Michelle Richards Mescall

The Irish Coffee Pub was a dream to work with!

The Knot Testimonials

The Irish Coffee Pub was a dream to work with! Stephen and all of his crew provided us with the most professional and heartfelt service in the wedding industry! From our very first meeting to our wedding day, we were treated with prompt service and respect. This team is extremely organized, detail-oriented, and genuinely kind. Our wedding at Martha Clara was complete with the help of them. Our guests could not stop raving about the delicious food and exquisite service. Multiple people have told us that it was the best wedding food they have ever tasted and I would have to agree! We thank you from the bottom of our hearts!

Danielle Y

Truly outstanding!

This wonderful establishment catered my daughter, Megan Minutillo’s wedding. Words cannot do it justice. Stephen is a genius. Every single detail was attended, even before you would ask. The food was unbelievable,(best baby lamb chops, short ribs, ahi tuna, and and and…)presentation perfect, service beyond excellent. I’m sorry it’s over, but thank God we can go to the restaurant any time. Truly outstanding!

Luci Pagliai Minutillo

SO glad we chose ICP for our wedding!

Wedding Wire TestimonialsMy wedding was held here yesterday, 12.2.2017. My husband and I had joked around for years about getting married here, and then we just did it. the food was amazing, the staff were so helpful, and Michael (our wedding attendant) was SO incredibly helpful all day. We are SO glad we chose ICP for our wedding!


Go with Irish Coffee Pub!

Wedding Wire Testimonials

We got married at Martha Clara Vineyards on June 25, 2016 and if you ever get married there or need a caterer elsewhere: go with Irish Coffee Pub! For starters, Stephen, the caterer, is on top of EVERYTHING! He was incredibly attentive to our questions and was always available to meet when we needed (my husband and I live in Washington, DC and often had very narrow windows of time to meet). He knew the venue inside and out, and, because of his great leadership and highly professional staff, everything went along smoothly.The food was absolutely delicious; I keep getting compliments on the food–not only that, but he made sure my husband and I had time to actually eat at our own wedding. And it was so affordable! Irish Coffee Pub not only serves amazing meals, but the cake and glassware/flatware rentals are included in the price. Plus, Stephen has an amazing Irish brogue, how could you not love that?


Stephen at the Irish Coffee Pub simply went above and beyond all expectations

Wedding Wire Testimonials

We cannot give enough praise to Stephen and his staff at the Irish Coffee Pub for the work they put in to our wedding at Bedell Cellars in Cutchogue! We had originally booked a different caterer, but due to a series of unfortunate events, we were left without a caterer and needed to find an alternative. It ended up being a blessing in disguise, because Stephen at the Irish Coffee Pub simply went above and beyond all expectations and gave us the wedding of our dreams. He was very responsive to all of our requests, and always made time to meet with us. He is very detail-oriented and committed to delivering for his clients. All of our guests were blown away by the quality of the food and service. I cannot think of anyone I would rather have catering an event than Stephen and his staff. Thanks Stephen!

Wonderful venue for a small gathering

Our 50th Nursing School Anniversary was approaching and although we are scattered across the U.S. we wanted to get together. It was difficult to find a place with a small room to accommodate us and we really did not want to just go to a restaurant.
My friend Linda and I went to check out the rooms and we were shown Dublin Court. It was beautiful and just what we needed. The fireplace was an elegant focal point and we were able to add our own touches to customize it with memorabilia.
Stephen was wonderful assisting us with food and beverage choices.
The day of the party Jose was assigned as the main server and he was very helpful.
Food was delicious and service was great….I apologize because we overstayed our welcome as no one wanted to leave!
Planning was a seamless affair.
If you are in need of a private room for a small group look no further!
Kathie Cotnoir

Kathleen Cotnoir

The Best in the Business

We had Irish Coffee Pub cater our wedding at RGNY (formerly Martha Clara Vineyard). I don’t think I could possibly write enough good things about Irish Coffee Pub. First, I would like to start with Stephen, the Owner. From the first moment we met he was an absolute professional. At the initial tasting, he went through every detail of the wedding. He was so thorough with his preparations that we barely had any questions. Even before we tried our first appetizer I was sold. Katie, Stephen’s events manager, was just as excellent as Stephen. Anytime there was a problem, I knew Stephen or Katie would have a solution. The food was absolutely fantastic. High quality food at a fair price, excellent staff, and an Owner who cares enough to cultivate relationships with his clients and treat them like family. You can tell why ICP has been around for so long. They do it the right way. They were so wonderful we also had them cater our rehearsal dinner. Whether is was 40 people at the rehearsal or 200 at the wedding, the quality and professionalism did not change. Don’t let the name deter you. Their menu is not merely Irish food. Their menu is so expansive and they were willing to add or remove some ingredients to accommodate our wants and needs.I can’t say enough about how amazing their food is. Stephen was on site for the Rehearsal and the Wedding to ensure everything ran smoothly. Their outside relationships with other vendors such as the Florist, Bakery for the Wedding Cake, RGNY, and others, made the whole process seamless. I would absolutely recommend ICP for any event you are looking for. Stephen and Katie thank you so much for helping us have the perfect wedding. You have a new customer for life!

Michael Tavella

Nothing short of outstanding

The Knot Testimonials

The Irish Coffee Pub was nothing short of outstanding. My husband and I worked closely with Niall and we were later introduced to Megan, who was our Maitre D the night of our wedding. They were absolutely amazing. We met with Niall a few months before our upcoming wedding date on October 9th and decided to work with him immediately. He is such a warm and easygoing person… someone you need when you have your wedding fast approaching. He was very transparent and always available when I needed to talk to him. He set up a tasting for my parents, in-laws, and my husband and I about a month before our wedding to lock in what we wanted. Megan and Niall came to my in-laws backyard (our newest wedding venue) and before leaving told me that they had everything covered- open bar, passed apps, dinner, dessert, tables, etc. They made the process completely effortless. Fast forward to our wedding, Megan handled everything, I felt like a guest at my own wedding. Niall came by as well to check in. The servers, bartenders, Megan, and Niall were extraordinary. Irish Coffee Pub is my family’s new favorite place… we even ordered some of the dishes from our wedding because the food was SO incredible. We cannot thank them enough. If you need catering for a wedding or ANY event… this is your place.

Kate C

Best. Wedding. Ever!

Irish coffee pub was an absolute DREAM to work with for my wedding! The entire event was planned in about 2 months and the owner Stephen was an absolute gem! He made planning so easy, and was the nicest sweetest guy to speak with. The food was OUTSTANDING, all of my guests are still raving about it. Having a wedding in December, I wanted all the Christmas feels, and the decorations did not disappoint! The room was beautiful, and the entire night went so smoothly. I could not recommend Irish coffee pub enough!! Thanks for making our special day so memorable.

Kim Carlo

30 years of excellent dining

My wife and I have been dining at the coffee pub for 30 years
From the days with Jimmy singing in the snug till now,
The food , service , staff has been excellent.. especially Steven and Nail for always
Making us feel so welcome
Looking forward to more wonderful times at our favorite

Cliff & Linda ward

Cliff ward

Irish Coffee Pub truly went above and beyond

The Knot Testimonials

Irish Coffee Pub truly went above and beyond to make our wedding day as special as it could have been. We had a DIY backyard wedding for ~160 people. They provided all their own equipment to cook an array of incredible meals. They also accommodated our own special requests to make the menu and experience our own while providing their expertise and guidance to make sure the menu was well rounded enough to be enjoyed by all of our guests.Our friends are still talking about how good the steak and short rib was a month later.

Stephen also helped us in managing rentals, coordinated fantastically with the other vendors and he and his team went out of their way to make sure that the rain we had to deal with was only a minor disruption to an otherwise great day.

We can’t thank Stephen, Megan and the whole Irish Coffee Pub team enough. Anyone in the Long Island area looking for a catering team that will truly do it all would be lucky to work with them.

Leave a Review

Strong Testimonials form submission spinner.


What is your full name?
What is your email address?
A headline for your testimonial.
What do you think about us?